Judge Patrick McNulty's job in the precedent-setting sexual harassment case was to set a dollar value on the emotional, financial and physical damages 16 women suffered during more than a decade of sexual harassment.
McNulty, 74, a part-time federal magistrate judge in Duluth, Minn., decided their suffering wasn't worth much, by the standards of modern litigation. He awarded 16 women a combined $182,500. That's an average of about $11,400 each, at a time some experts say jury verdicts to individual plaintiffs in sexual harassment cases are averaging $250,000 each.
In the Eveleth mine case, transcripts of McNulty's intermittent six-month trial and his detailed, 416-page report on the damages suggest that the semi-retired judge was skeptical of the women's stories.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.